
One name, many variations. As it is with many cocktails, the El Presidente has two main families of variations, quite a bit of variation within those families. One family is French-Italian, and basically a Manhattan with rum. The other family is a Sour, and basically a Daquiri plus. But the theme running throughout is orange.
I’ll start with the only recipe that has a definite attribution:
Esquire Drinks (Wondrich, 2002)
1.5 oz light rum
0.5 oz orange curacao
0.75 oz dry vermouth
dash grenadine
Wondrich attributes this to Eddie Woelke of Havana’s Jockey Club, invented in honor of Gerardo Machado, cattle rustler who became the 5th president of Cuba 1925, and lost power in 1933. This recipe is attributed to bartender George Stadelman at Club El Chico in New York (attribution is from 1949 Equire Handbook for Hosts). No specific date is given, but it it has to have been sometime during Machado’s reign. It’s also possible that this comes from a more generic Presidente recipe, and that only this specific variation was named to honor Machado.
The 1930 Savoy Cocktail Book doesn’t list a Presidente, but it does list this:
President Cocktial
1 glass Bacardi rum (2 oz)
Juice 1/4 Orange
2 dashes grenadine
No vermouth, but the orange juice would act both to give an orange flavor (although a juice rather than oil flavor) and as a moderating agent.

Angostura Recipes, 1934
El Presidente Cocktail
1.5 oz light rum
0.75 oz curacao
0.75 oz sweet vermouth
Stirred, with maraschino cherry (only one stirred or with m.c.)
Slightly different proportions, sweet vs. dry vermouth, and no grenadine. However, the maraschino cherry and the bit of liquid with it would lend some red fruit flavor. The sweetness in the vermouth would also offset the loss of the sweetness from the grenadine. (Why Angostura chose a toreador as the illustration for the cocktail, I’ll never know.)
While all of the others have rum, this one contains Kentucky whisky, which we know of know as bourbon. Today, Brown Forman is the distributor for Appleton Estates rum, but in 1934 they had only “domestic” spirits. So this is basically a wet Manhattan with curacao instead of bitters (which are similar flavors).

How to Make Old Kentucky Famed Drinks, from Brown Forman Distillery, 1934
Presidente
1.5 oz whisky
1 oz dry vermouth
2 dashes orange curacao
In the Joy of Mixology, Regan gives a recipe adapted from 1949 Old Mr. Boston:
2 oz light rum
0.5 oz lime juice
0.5 oz pineapple juice
dash grenadine
Quite different: rum-based, but with enough lime to categorize it as a Sour, and more precisely as a Daquiri variation. The pineapple acts as the moderator, and the grenadine of the original. None of the other recipes have lime, even though it’s commonly paired with rum. How could the recipes be so different? Looking in my copy of Mr Boston 1963, we get the answers:
El Presidente Cocktail No. 1
Juice of 1 lime
1 tsp pineapple juice
1 tsp grenadine
1.5 oz rum
El Presidente Cocktail No. 2
0.75 oz dry vermouth
1.5 oz rum
dash bitters
No. 1 is the base for the one in JoM, although with updated proportions, and No.2 the more traditional recipe. No. 2 is the only one of the lot to have betters instead of curacao, but one guess that orange bitters were used in practice.
So, naturally, since there are so many recipes, I’ll formulate my own. There are a few things I wanted to showcase here: Stirrings Blood Orange Bitters, homemade maraschino cherries, and homemade grenadine. I just got the Stirrings last week, from Kegworks via eBay. The cherry season in Oregon just ended, but I’ve been making wonderful maraschinos with Maraska for the past few weeks. The grenadine I made last weekend (post coming soon). So the recipe:
El Presidente (var. 1)
1.5 oz Myer’s light rum
0.5 oz Stirrings Blood Orange bitters
0.75 oz dry vermouth
1 tsp grenadine
homemade marschino cherry
Stirrings Blood Orange bitters are much less bitter than a traditional orange bitter, and they contain sugar (umm…), so more than a dash is required. I perceive them as even less bitter than Campari. Since there’s no acidifying agent, it’s not possible to get the taste of the grenadine to appear without making the drink sweet (particularly with the Stirrings). The rum isn’t as strong a flavor as gin or rye in similar drinks, so it doesn’t really give the drink the backbone that it should. I’d really like this as a not-too-sweet cordial, particularly with the cherry treat at the end.